Bad Competative Analysis and Keyword Prominence Vs. Stuffing - Unknown Secrets of SEO E-Webstyle Number 14
Episode31 min2009-10-21
Competitive analysis in SEO means studying first-page rivals for keyword frequency, title ratios, and inbound links, while avoiding black hat tactics like keyword stuffing that can get your site banned.
Key takeaways
- Use tools like Web Position Gold Page Critic to compare your keyword frequency, word count, and ratios against first-page competitors.
- A first-page ranking does not guarantee conversions. A clear call to action on a lower-ranked site can outperform a top-ranked one.
- Copying a competitor's exact webpage text places your site in the supplemental index because Google treats it as duplicate content.
- The SEO learning curve is slow because every change requires waiting weeks or a month to measure results.
great search engine placement and great traffic does not equal sales
About this episode
We discuss how not to do a website competitive analysis. We also discuss the importance of keyword prominence to SEO, keyword stuffing and issue that keywords stuffing can cause for your websites search engine placement. Also learn what the Google supplemental is and how to stay out of the supplemental.
Questions this episode answers
What is keyword prominence in SEO and why does it matter?
Keyword prominence refers to the ratio of your target keyword to total words in a given area like a title or heading. Tools like Web Position Gold suggest a prominence of around 60 to 68 percent in those areas, based on analysis of existing first-page websites, to help guide on-page optimization.
Can keyword stuffing get my website banned from Google?
Yes. Placing keywords in tiny or hidden text is considered keyword stuffing. Google has software to detect it, and a competitor can also report you. When caught, getting out of the supplemental index is difficult and can seriously damage a business that depends on search traffic.
How do I do competitive analysis for SEO?
Pull up the first-page competitors for your target keyword, then analyze their keyword frequency, word count, and keyword-to-word ratios in the title, heading, URL, and body text. Tools like Web Position Gold Page Critic and Advanced Web Ranking are mentioned as useful for this work.
Why should I not just copy what a competitor is doing on their website?
A competitor may be using black hat SEO techniques that could get your site banned. Copying their exact page text also triggers duplicate content issues and sends your site to the supplemental index. Study what they do, but apply it using proper, approved methods.
In their words
you don't just want to go and if you're the kind of person that can look at their source code, I'm just going to cut and paste and copy this here. They might be doing something they're not supposed to be doing.
Paul Hanson
if the growth and your business is dependent on Google and you're using any sort of black hat techniques, you may last a year. You know, maybe throwing cash in your pocket and that's great. And then, that day when you get caught and you get banned, everything changes
Chris Burris
Terms defined in this episode
- Keyword Prominence
- The ratio of a target keyword to total words in a specific page area such as the title or heading. Web Position Gold suggests around 60 to 68 percent prominence based on analysis of first-page websites.
- Keyword Stuffing
- Placing excessive keywords in tiny or hidden text on a page to manipulate rankings. Google can detect and ban sites for this, and competitors can report it.
- Supplemental Index
- A secondary Google index where pages with duplicate or low-quality content are placed, effectively removing them from normal search results.
- Page Critic
- A feature inside Web Position Gold that analyzes keyword frequency, word count, and keyword prominence ratios in the title, heading, URL, and body text of top-ranking pages.
Full transcript is being added.
Matthew Bertram
AI keynote speaker · Owner & CEO, EWR Digital · President, ModalPoint
Matthew Bertram is an AI keynote speaker, creator of DIG™ (Digital Information Governance), and owner and CEO of EWR Digital. He helps energy and industrial leaders win visibility in AI search (GEO and AEO), is President of ModalPoint and CMO of the Oil & Gas Global Network, hosts The Best SEO Podcast, and has authored eight books including LLM Visibility. More about Matthew Bertram.
Related episodes
Episode · 30 min · Transcript
In this episode we discuss competitive analysis, the value of keywords and how to tell if you have a horrible website. We discuss the value of meta…
SEO Strategy
Episode · 26 min · Transcript
In this episode we cover how to avoid SEO sabotage, yes SEO sabotage. There are ways that your website could get sabotaged by your older SEO company…
SEO Strategy
Episode · 26 min · Transcript
Internet Marketing In this episode we cover SEO vs Yellow Pages and should you submit videos to YouTube if you are working on your own site for SEO.…
SEO Strategy
Episode · 33 min · Transcript
What is SEO and how can it provide a Return On Investment
SEO Strategy
The show explains it. EWR Digital does it.
The Best SEO Podcast breaks down SEO and AI search; EWR Digital, the agency behind the show, implements it for operators. Start with a free, no-pitch audit of where you stand in Google and in AI answers.
Get a free AI visibility audit